geneAttribution: Identification of Candidate Genes Associated with Noncoding Genetic Variation

Arthur Wuster

2021-10-27

geneAttribution is an R package for identifying the most likely gene or genes through which variation at a given genomic locus in the human genome acts. A typical use case is the annotation of results from genome-wide association studies (GWAS). The majority of variants identified by GWAS are located in noncoding regions and likely act by affecting gene expression (Maurano et al. 2012). Variants typically contain multiple genes in the region of linkage disequilibrium and identifying the causative one is challenging.

The most basic functionality of geneAttribution assumes that the closer gene is to the input locus, the more likely the gene is to be causative. Additionally, any empirical data that links genomic regions to genes (e.g. expression quantitative trait loci (eQTL) or genome conformation data) can be used if it is supplied in the UCSC .BED file format.

Basic functionality

# Basic workflow, default parameters
library(geneAttribution)
geneLocs <- geneModels() # Define gene models
geneAttribution("chr2", 127156000, geneLocs) # Get candidate gene probabilities

The most basic functionality assumes that the closer a gene is to the input locus, the more likely it is to be a candidate gene. The relationship between distance to locus and candidate gene likelihood is modeled as an exponential distribution. The likelihoods for each gene are then normalized by dividing by the sum of likelihoods. As a result, the presence of multiple genes in the vicinity of a locus decreases the posterior probabilities of the individual genes.

geneModels()

To calculate the distance between the input locus and genes, gene models are required. For this, geneAttribution provides the geneModels() function. geneModels() takes a TxDb object containing genomic coordinates of genes as input and returns gene models in GenomicRanges format, with gene names in the symbol column. Loading the gene models may take a few minutes. The default for the TxDb input is TxDb.Hsapiens.UCSC.hg38.knownGene, which contains gene models for genome build GRCh38. An alternative input would be TxDb.Hsapiens.UCSC.hg19.knownGene, which contains gene models for build hg19. The geneModels function has additional optional input:

geneAttribution()

The minimum required input for geneAttribution() is a chromosome identifier in the same format than in the gene models and a chromosomal position in the same build than the gene models. The geneAttribution() function has additional optional input:

Using empirical data

# Typical workflow, using sample data supplied with geneAttribution
geneLocs <- geneModels()
fileName1 <- system.file("extdata", "hiCRegions.b38.bed", package="geneAttribution")
fileName2 <- system.file("extdata", "eqtlHaplotypeBlocks.b38.bed", package="geneAttribution")
empirical <- loadBed(c(fileName1, fileName2), c(2, 5))
geneAttribution("chr2", 127156000, geneLocs, empirical)

# As above, but with user-supplied empirical data file in UCSC .BED format
geneLocs <- geneModels()
empirical <- loadBed("INPUT_FILE.bed", weights=1.5) # INPUT_FILE.bed is a correctly formatted .BED file
geneAttribution("chr2", 127156000, geneLocs, empirical)

In addition, geneAttribution can make use of empirical data that links genomic loci to genes. eQTLs, which link genetic variants to the expression of specific genes, are an example of this. If the input locus is located inside the regions defined in the empirical data, the likelihood of the associated gene is multiplied by the associated weighting. User-provided empirical data can be loaded by using the loadBed() function.

The loadBed funtion reads user-provided files in UCSC .BED format. .BED files must be tab-separated and the columns must be in the following order: chromosome, start, end, gene symbol. An optional fifth score column may also be provided. Gene symbols used in the empirical data must match the symbols used for the gene models and the genome build (e.g. GRCh38) must also match the genome build of the gene models.

Together with the .BED files, weightings for the data may be provided. The default for this is 2, which doubles the likelihoods for genes if the input locus is located in a region defined by the empirical data. A weighting of 1 would not change the likelihood, and a weighting of less than 1 would decrease the likelihood. Alternatively to reading .BED files, users may construct empirical data themselves as a list of GenomicRanges objects with a score column containing the weights.

The extdata directory provides two .BED files in genome build GRCh38:

Because both files are supplied as examples, they are limited to a 10 MB region (120,000,000-130,000,000) on chromosome 2.

Obtaining the coordinates of candidate genes

The output of the geneAttribution function is a named numerical vector of candidate gene probabilities. In some instances, it may be useful to also know the coordinates of the candidate genes, as this annotation can help with further work with package results. It can easily be obtained by subsetting the gene models object.

geneLocs <- geneModels()
geneLocs <- geneModels() # Define gene models
pp <- geneAttribution("chr2", 127156000, geneLocs, minPP=0) # Posterior prob.
geneLocs[match(names(pp), geneLocs$symbol)] # Subset gene models